|
|
|
September 1995 |
NEW, EMERGING AND RE-EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES
Goals and Objectives Strategies Bibliography
Introduction
In the Americas, a complex array of factors has contributed to the recognition of an increasing number of new, emerging, and re-emerging infectious diseases in both developed and developing nations. Cholera, for example, returned to the Western Hemisphere in epidemic proportions in 1991. Since then, over one million cases and 9,000 deaths have occurred. In 1993 and 1994, the number of reported cases decreased in some countries but continued to increase in several areas of Central America, Brazil, and Argentina. PAHO has estimated that it will take more than a decade and over US$ 200 billion to control the regional epidemic. Factors contributing to the resurgence of cholera include poor public sanitation, inadequate water treatment, and high levels of poverty associated with unsatisfactory living conditions. The cholera problem also illustrates how factors in one continent may affect global health through increased microbial traffic to distant regions.
In Peru, sporadic cases of human plague have been reported for the past 40 to 50 years. However, in October 1992, a plague epidemic emerged. By the end of 1994, a total of 1,299 cases were
diagnosed, with 62 deaths and a case fatality rate of 4.8%.
Antimicrobial drug resistance is perhaps one of the most alarming threats among the problems presented by new and emerging infections. The problem is well documented in the United States where increasing levels of drug resistance in both community-acquired (e.g., multi-drug-resistant Streptococcus pneumoniae) and nosocomial infections (e.g., vancomycin-resistant enterococci) have
led infectious disease experts to declare the situation a crisis that could lead to a "post-antibiotic" era. Although less well-documented, the detection of significant levels of antimicrobial drug resistance is increasing in Latin America where, for example, over 20% of strains of S. pneumoniae have diminished susceptibility to penicillin. Resistance is also spreading among Latin American strains of Shigella, and high-level resistance is anticipated to develop in Salmonella typhi in the near future. Although documentation is limited, the threat of antimicrobial resistance in the developing nations of the Western Hemisphere appears to outweigh that present in the United States and Canada. Resistant Plasmodium falciparum malaria is now present throughout P. falciparum-endemic regions in South America. Resistance to chloroquine was soon followed by resistance to sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine combinations. Diminished sensitivity to quinine has been reported in Brazil. Conditions that encourage the development of antimicrobial resistance are widespread throughout Latin America: over-the-counter sale of antibiotics and frequent self-medication; overcrowding and suboptimal infection control practices in many hospitals; minimal regulation of antibiotic usage within or outside hospitals; scarce documentation of clinical trial results for newer antibiotics; and almost nonexistent surveillance and reporting of antimicrobial resistance patterns.
Human immunodeficiency virus infection/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (HIV/ AIDS) may be the most devastating example of the potential impact of a newly emerging infectious disease on global public health. The HIV/AIDS pandemic has been pivotal in drawing the attention of public health experts to the problem and to the need for increased surveillance and research. HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) illustrate the impact of changes in demographic conditions, social standards, modification of the global environment, and the mutability of microorganisms. The discovery of HIV has also led to the identification of other etiologic agents with similar modes of transmission through sexual contact, blood contamination, and perinatal acquisition, such as HTLV-I- and HTLV-II-associated myelopathy/tropical spastic paraparesis in the Caribbean and Brazil.
The Pan American Health Organization estimates that over 1.5 million people in Latin America and the Caribbean are infected with HIV and that by 1999 the cost of caring for AIDS patients in the entire Region will exceed $2,000 million. The dramatic impact of HIV/AIDS on public health is due in large part to the multiple opportunistic infections that develop in association with this condition. Data from Brazil, Honduras, Argentina, and Mexico indicate that tuberculosis is the most common opportunistic infection in the Region, afflicting over 330,000 persons in 1992. Co-infection with HIV and M. tuberculosis substantially increases the pool of individuals with active pulmonary disease, thus increasing the risk of contagion to both immunosuppressed and non-immunosuppressed persons. In addition, such patients frequently harbor strains of M. tuberculosis with multiple drug resistance. This complex interplay between HIV and M. tuberculosis, in association with decreasing support for tuberculosis surveillance and control programs, accounts for part of the recent resurgence of this condition in the United States of America, where direct costs for tuberculosis treatment in 1991 alone exceeded $700 million. The economic impact in Latin America and the Caribbean has yet to be documented.
HIV/AIDS is interacting with new and emerging infectious diseases in other ways as well. Common tropical diseases in Latin America, such as Chagas' disease, are presenting with varied and unusual clinical manifestations in persons with HIV/AIDS. Moreover, experience with some HIV-related infections has led to their increased recognition in broader populations, such asCryptosporidium in diarrheal disease outbreaks associated with childcare facilities and contaminated municipal water supplies in the United States. Even "new" diseases such as human microsporidiosis are being recognized with increasing frequency because of the expanding population of persons with HIV/AIDS. Three new species of microsporidia (Enterocytozoon bieneusi, Encephalitozoon hellem, and Encephalitozoon [formerly Septata] intestinalis) were first described in HIV-infected individuals from North America and the Caribbean. HIV has also been found to affect susceptibility to cervical and other cancers. In the case of another sexually transmitted agent, human papillomavirus (HPV), the relationship between certain strains of HPV and the development of cervical cancer have been well established. Cervical cancer, the leading cause of death from cancer among women in developing countries, is expected to increase because HIV-induced immunosuppression facilitates HPV-induced neoplasia.
Although worldwide in scope, the emergence of dengue and dengue hemorrhagic fever (DHF) as a major public health problem has been most dramatic in the Americas, where the mean annual number of
reported DHF cases between 1989 and 1993 increased over 60-fold as compared to the preceding five-year period (1984-1988). Dengue has now become hyperendemic (types 1, 2, and 4) in many countries in the American tropics; during the last 10 years, five countries in South America have experienced major epidemics, following a period of over 50 years in which the disease was largely absent. The geographic distribution of Aedes aegypti in 1995 is similar to its distribution prior to the successful eradication campaigns of the 1950s and 1960s. As of this year, 15 countries in the Region of the Americas had reported confirmed cases of DHF, and DHF is now endemic in many of these countries. In 1994 dengue type 3 virus activity was detected in Nicaragua and Panama and in 1995, in Costa Rica, Honduras, and El Salvador, representing the first reappearance of this strain in the Americas in 16 years.
The South American arenaviruses provide an important example of how exploitation of new areas for human settlement and agriculture will increase the likelihood that new infectious diseases will emerge. A new member of this group of rodent-borne viruses has been discovered on an average of every three years since the first was isolated in 1956. Some are not pathogenic for humans, but five cause human disease and three of these cause important health problems in Argentina (Junín virus: Argentine hemorrhagic fever), Bolivia (Machupo virus: Bolivian hemorrhagic fever), and Venezuela (Guanarito virus: Venezuelan hemorrhagic fever). The pattern of these emerging infections is that humans become involved when they enter new areas where viruses are circulating among wild rodents and that the viruses may spread to involve wide geographic areas.
Yellow fever mainly affects five countries of the tropical Americas. It occurs sporadically or causes relatively small outbreaks among persons exposed to the infection in forests where it is enzootic. The disease re-emerged with dramatic force in Peru in 1995, causing the largest outbreak in the country's history. Nearly 400 cases have been notified (provisional figure), with a case-fatality rate approaching 50%.
Vulnerability to emerging infections is not limited to the developing nations of tropical America. In 1993, the United States experienced the largest waterborne disease outbreak ever recognized there. The source was an urban municipal water supply contaminated with Cryptosporidium-an intestinal parasite that causes prolonged diarrheal illness in the immunocompetent and severe, often life-threatening, disease in the immunosuppressed. Also in 1993, the emerging bacterial pathogen Escherichia coli O157:H7 caused a multi-state foodborne outbreak of hemorrhagic colitis and hemolytic uremic syndrome, with at least four deaths among infected children.
Likewise, a previously unknown hantavirus was identified in the four-corner area of the United States (Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Utah) as the etiologic agent of hantavirus pulmonary syndrome. This infection, which was linked to exposure to infected rodents, has affected primarily otherwise healthy young adults and has demonstrated a cumulative mortality approaching 50%. Over 100
cases have been identified in 22 states in the United States; Canada has reported seven cases. Elsewhere in the Americas, recognition of hantavirus is also increasing. Three cases, with two deaths, have been confirmed in Brazil, while Argentina has recently released data suggesting that three outbreaks of hantavirus pulmonary syndrome occurred in that country between 1991 and 1995.
Regional Plan of Action
In recent years considerable attention has been given to the serious threat posed by new, emerging, and re-emerging infectious diseases. The magnitude of the problem is illustrated by the appearance of several new pathogens causing disease of marked severity, such as the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and other retroviruses, arenaviruses, hantaviruses, and Ebola virus. Simultaneously, old pathogens, including those which cause cholera, plague, dengue hemorrhagic fever, and yellow fever, have re-emerged and are having a considerable impact in the Americas. Microorganism mutations leading to drug and multi-drug-resistant strains of mycobacterium, tuberculosis, enterobacteria, staphylococci, pneumococci, gonococci, malaria parasites, and other agents have been occurring continuously and are becoming major obstacles to the control of these infections. Some of these infections exhibit a focal geographic distribution, whereas others are widely dispersed and, in some cases, tend to become a global problem.
In response to this alarming trend, in June 1995 PAHO convened a meeting of international experts to discuss strategies for the prevention and control of new, emerging, and re-emerging diseases. As result of this meeting, a Regional Plan of Action was prepared to develop regional and subregional approaches and to guide Member States in addressing specific problems.
Goals and Objectives
The goals and objectives of the Plan are as allows:
Goal 1: Strengthening regional surveillance networks for infectious diseases in the Americas
The purpose of regional surveillance networks is to provide the vigilance and rapid response capability required to better detect, contain, and prevent new and resurgent infectious diseases in the Americas. Such networks should monitor infectious agents, the diseases they cause, and the factors influencing their emergence. Well-run surveillance networks are invaluable tools for disease monitoring and assessment. Specifically, surveillance serves to: characterize disease patterns by time, place, and person; detect epidemics; generate hypotheses for epidemiologic investigation; evaluate prevention and control programs; project future health care needs; and lower health care expenditures by facilitating earlier implementation of intervention strategies. Surveillance networks that are closely linked with reference diagnostic support function as early warning systems for emerging infections.
Ojectives:
Goal 2: Establishing national and regional infrastructures for early warning of and rapid response to infectious disease threats through laboratory enhancement and multidisciplinary training programs
Careful design of the components needed to ensure appropriate resource development and integration of those resources among local, national, subregional, and regional partners should facilitate the establishment of truly useful infrastructures. Components of a program for early warning and rapid response to emerging infections should include:
Objectives:
Goal 3: Promoting the further development of applied research in the areas of rapid diagnosis, epidemiology, and prevention
With the exception of Region-wide emerging infectious threats such as cholera, tuberculosis, and HIV, disease-specific research priorities will likely be developed on a country-by-country basis. Some general principles, however, can be used when assessing priority applied research needs for new and emerging infections in the Americas. For purposes of discussion, these principles can be classified into three broad categories: diagnostics, epidemiology/prevention effectiveness, and clinical studies.
Objectives:
Goal 4: Strengthening the regional capacity for effective implementation of prevention and control strategies
Prevention and control strategies will complement Goals 1-3 and can be viewed as the "action" and "feedback" components of the Regional Plan of Action. Emphasis will be placed on information dissemination systems/programs, aggressive efforts to develop and rapidly implement educational programs on antimicrobial resistance, and enhancement of emergency response and outbreak control measures.
Objectives:
Strategies
The following strategic approaches have been established
for
each of the defined goals of the Regional Plan of Action.
1. Strengthening regional surveillance networks for infectious
diseases in the Americas
Several surveillance networks are presently functioning in the Americas. Some of these networks, such as those for polio and measles, were established as part of eradication programs. Their role has been very valuable in documenting the elimination of these diseases. The cholera network was established after the re-emergence of this disease in the Americas and provides useful information on its distribution in the Region. The WHONET was developed by the World Health Organization for use in laboratories to monitor antimicrobial resistance and guide the selection of antibiotics, and to identify resistance and quality control problems, at both national and international levels. The influenza and dengue networks and the WHO Collaborating Centers are examples of other networks making significant contributions to the surveillance of infectious diseases in the Americas. In addition, the Caribbean Epidemiology Center (CAREC), the Pan American Foot-and-Mouth Disease Center (PANAFTOSA), and the Pan American Institute for Food Protection and Zoonoses (INPPAZ) have important functions in the surveillance of human and animal diseases. It should also be noted that the Integrated Border Information and Surveillance System (IBISS) for monitoring health events in the United States-Mexico border region is currently under development.
Regional leadership and coordination are necessary to enhance these existing capacities by strengthening and linking established laboratories and surveillance facilities. Advantage should be taken of modern technologies in information management, exchange, and dissemination, such as geographic information systems (GIS), the Public Health Laboratory Information System (PHLIS), and the Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) connections.
Consideration should be given to establishing a regional committee for emerging infectious disease surveillance to develop priorities and enhance regional surveillance, in close coordination with the countries of the Region. The committee could include representatives of leading institutions in these countries.
The purpose of the surveillance should be to detect, promptly investigate, and monitor emerging pathogens, the diseases they cause, and the factors influencing their emergence. In this context, three lines of surveillance should be considered:
2. Establishing national and regional infrastructures for early warning of and rapid response to emerging infectious disease threats through laboratory enhancement and multidisciplinary training programs
To establish the appropriate infrastructure to respond to a new disease threat, human resources, facilities for laboratory capacities and clinical training, communica-tions, logistical support, and organizational structure must be developed.
Appropriately trained personnel will be a critical component of the infrastructure needed for early warning and rapid response. Training programs should be carried out in partnership with the numerous national institutions that provide such training in the Americas. Particularly important will be the development of education and training activities targeted at practical issues of disease surveillance, recognition, and response. These activities should focus on the country-level medical community to facilitate appropriate specimen collection and handling, the laboratory resources for optimum specimen processing, and the intelligent utilization of data obtained by program managers. Training should also target country-level laboratory personnel. Collaborative programs with organizations in the United States of America and other countries are needed to train specialists in state-of-the-art, field-applicable, and cost-effective technologies.
Career development is essential. There must be a system for training skilled personnel for each of these roles and a career path to ensure retention. This is especially true for surveillance (both laboratory and epidemiologic), where there is often no developed career path and no career incentive. At both regional and national levels, contacts and partnerships with appropriate professional groups (and the development of appropriate groups, when none exist) should be encouraged.
It is necessary to define the complement of minimal laboratory (and epidemiologic) capabilities that should be available at each level (from the local, through national, to subregional and regional), develop guidelines and standard procedures, and assist governments in implementing these guidelines. There is also a need for a comprehensive survey of suitable laboratory and epidemiological facilities and for an assessment of their capabilities. This should be done through questionnaires and (as necessary) visits. As a start, all known laboratory networks
should be listed and assessed. Regional quality assurance and
quality control programs for diagnostic laboratories need to be
implemented. Guidelines should be available for sample collection, handling, and storage. Regional self-sufficiency in diagnostics is a goal, with the more specialized reagents produced, at least
initially, by appropriate specialized laboratories; the reagents would then be standardized and inventoried regionally. Technology
transfer of laboratory diagnostic tests should be encouraged, including appropriate
ways to evaluate and utilize tests that might
be of particular value in the Region.
Different communication mechanisms
are appropriate at
different levels, with fax and electronic communications being the
major options beyond the local level. Implementing a small number
of well-standardized and well-established systems, such as PHLIS
(with EPI-INFO) and WHONET (for antimicrobial resistance data),
would facilitate data sharing and coordination.
Logistical support must be assured at regional level for the
provision of diagnostic reagents, supplies, and equipment. At
national level, systems must exist for specimen collection and
transport from original sites to laboratories.
3. Promoting the further development of applied research in the
areas of rapid diagnosis, epidemiology and prevention
Under the category of applied research are included
diagnostics, treatment, prevention, surveillance, development of
products, and studies of socioeconomic factors affecting disease transmission.
Each country must determine its own emerging disease priority list. Obviously, the applied research needs will vary, depending
on the diseases selected. In many countries, basic epidemiologic
information about emerging diseases is still lacking. Research is
needed on the prevalence, morbidity/mortality, geographic
distribution, risk factors, and presence or absence of appropriate
vectors and/or reservoirs, among others.
It is essential to standardize the clinical diagnosis and treatment of newly emerging diseases, and diagnostic protocols should be developed for the major emerging disease groups. Research is needed on the pathogenesis and spectrum of disease caused by emerging agents. This should include acute as well as chronic disease manifestations.
Development of rapid and simple diagnostic techniques for emerging pathogens should have high priority. It would be useful to develop reagents (e.g., recombinant antigens and well-characterized monoclonal antibodies) which could be produced by a
regional reference center or by local laboratories, depending on
their capabilities.
There should be more field application of molecular epidemiologic techniques. On the other hand, some molecular techniques are not within the capability or budget of every
laboratory. Studies of the cost effectiveness of various diagnostic tests should be carried out. There is often a tendency
to develop the newest high-tech (molecular) diagnostic test when it may be more cost-effective to continue using a simpler and older test which gives the same information.
Antimicrobial resistance is a growing
worldwide problem and a subject urgently needing research. Studies in this area should
include the control of antibiotics in animal feed and fish/shrimp
farms, testing of new drugs, and evaluation of therapies. Antimicrobial resistance should be studied in health care settings and in the community. It is important that the resulting
information be disseminated from researchers to users in the community.
Food- and waterborne diseases are another important area for
research. This should include studies of the economic, social, and
behavioral factors affecting disease transmission.
Partnerships should be encouraged between investigators in different countries in developing applied research programs. In an era of reduced funding, sharing of resources and knowledge makes good sense.
Development of vaccines and other preventive strategies should have high priority in applied research programs. There should also be periodic evaluation of the cost- effectiveness of different preventive and control measures.
More research is needed on the effects of social, behavioral, and ecologic factors/changes on disease emergence. Research in this area should include the development and testing of innovative interventions to control or prevent emerging diseases.
In many countries, vector control programs now have low priority and are not very effective Research is needed on
alternative vector control strategies. This should include
research on social and behavioral risk factors associated with
disease risk prevention. There is a growing need for field-trained
entomologists to study vector biology and behavior under field
conditions.
4.Strengthening the regional capacity for effective
implementation of prevention and control strategies
Consideration should be given to three broad areas related to
prevention and control strategies for emerging diseases in the
Americas:
Bibliography
Source: Division of Disease Prevention and Control, Communicable diseases Program, HCP/HCT, PAHO.
Return to topReturn to top
Return to top
Return to top
Return to top
Return to issue index